When to Hire a Tax Consultant Guide
Tax consultants focus exclusively on tax strategy and complex issues.
When to Hire a Tax Consultant
While your accountant handles day-to-day tax compliance, there are situations where specialist tax advice makes sense. Tax consultants focus exclusively on tax strategy and complex issues.
This guide helps you identify when specialist tax expertise can save money or prevent costly mistakes.
Accountants handle routine compliance: returns, VAT, PAYE. Tax consultants specialize in complex planning, disputes, restructuring, and cross-border issues. Many work together for best results.
When You Need a Tax Consultant
SARS Disputes
Audits or assessments.
Restructuring
Business structure changes.
International
Cross-border transactions.
Tax Planning
Optimize tax position.
SARS Disputes & Audits
When to Get Help
SARS AuditRequired
Being audited by SARS.
Additional AssessmentRequired
SARS claims you owe more.
PenaltiesRequired
Significant penalties imposed.
QueriesRecommended
Complex SARS queries.
What They Do
Review PositionRequired
Assess strength of your case.
Prepare ResponseRequired
Draft technical submissions.
NegotiateRequired
Engage with SARS on your behalf.
AppealConditional
Handle objections and appeals.
Act quickly on SARS notices. Response deadlines are strict. A tax consultant can help you understand options and prepare a proper response within required timeframes.
Business Restructuring
Restructuring Triggers
Changing Entity TypeRequired
Sole prop to company, etc.
Mergers/AcquisitionsRequired
Buying or selling business.
Group RestructureRecommended
Reorganizing company group.
Exit StrategyConditional
Planning ownership exit.
Tax Implications
CGTRequired
Capital Gains Tax on transfers.
Transfer PricingRequired
Intercompany transactions.
VATRecommended
VAT on asset transfers.
STTConditional
Securities Transfer Tax.
Plan before acting. Many restructuring options have specific requirements for tax relief. Getting advice after the fact may mean missing opportunities or triggering unexpected taxes.
International Matters
Cross-Border Situations
Foreign IncomeRequired
Earning income abroad.
Foreign InvestmentRequired
Investing outside SA.
Import/ExportRequired
International trading.
Foreign EmployeesRecommended
Expats or remote workers.
Complex Issues
Double Tax TreatiesRequired
Which country taxes what.
Withholding TaxesRequired
Taxes on cross-border payments.
CFC RulesRequired
Controlled Foreign Company.
Exchange ControlConditional
SARB reporting requirements.
International tax is extremely complex. Different rules apply depending on countries involved, type of income, and whether treaties exist. Get specialist advice for any cross-border matters.
Tax Planning
Planning Opportunities
Annual ReviewRecommended
Optimize before year-end.
Major TransactionsRecommended
Large sales or purchases.
Investment StructuringConditional
How to hold investments.
Remuneration PlanningConditional
Salary vs dividends.
Legitimate Planning
Legal MethodsRequired
Use permitted deductions.
TimingRequired
Manage when income is recognized.
StructuresRecommended
Appropriate entity choices.
IncentivesConditional
Available tax incentives.
Avoid aggressive schemes. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. SARS actively pursues aggressive tax avoidance. Good consultants recommend legal planning, not schemes.
Special Situations
Industry-Specific
MiningConditional
Mining tax regime is complex.
Financial ServicesConditional
Special VAT and income rules.
PropertyConditional
Transfer duties, CGT, VAT choices.
Research & DevelopmentConditional
R&D tax incentives.
Life Events
Selling BusinessRecommended
Exit planning and CGT.
EmigrationRecommended
Tax implications of leaving SA.
InheritanceConditional
Estate and donations tax.
DivorceConditional
Asset division implications.
Finding a Tax Consultant
Qualifications to Look For
Registered Tax PractitionerRequired
SARS registered.
Professional BodyRecommended
SAICA, SAIPA, SAIT membership.
Specialist ExpertiseRecommended
Experience in your issue.
Admitted AttorneyConditional
For litigation matters.
Selection Process
Define the Issue
What problem needs solving?
Get Referrals
Ask your accountant, lawyer.
Check Experience
Similar issues handled before?
Understand Fees
Get clear fee estimate.
Confirm Approach
Agree on strategy and timeline.
Your accountant can refer. Accountants often work with tax consultants on complex matters. They can recommend someone with the right expertise for your specific issue.
Working with Your Consultant
Your Responsibilities
Provide InformationRequired
Complete, accurate facts.
Respond PromptlyRequired
Tax matters are time-sensitive.
Be HonestRequired
Full disclosure required.
Understand AdviceRecommended
Ask questions if unclear.
Consultant Deliverables
Written OpinionRequired
Documented advice.
Risk AssessmentRequired
Likelihood of success.
Implementation StepsRecommended
How to execute the plan.
Supporting DocumentsConditional
Submissions, calculations.
Managing Costs
Fee Structures
Hourly RatesRequired
Common for complex matters.
Fixed FeesRecommended
For defined scope work.
Success FeesConditional
Sometimes for disputes.
RetainerConditional
Ongoing advisory relationship.
Value Assessment
Savings vs CostRequired
Will it pay for itself?
Risk MitigationRequired
Cost of getting it wrong?
Long-Term BenefitRecommended
Ongoing tax savings?
Peace of MindConditional
Value of certainty.
Good tax advice often pays for itself many times over. A R50,000 fee that saves R500,000 in tax is excellent value. Evaluate based on outcome, not just cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my accountant handle SARS disputes?
For simple matters, possibly. But complex audits, assessments, and appeals benefit from tax specialist expertise. Many accountants work together with tax consultants on disputes.
How much does tax consulting cost?
Rates vary widely based on complexity and expertise. Senior tax specialists charge R2,000-R5,000+ per hour. For defined projects, request a fixed fee quote.
Will SARS know I hired a tax consultant?
If the consultant corresponds with SARS on your behalf, yes. This isn't necessarily negative—SARS expects professional representation on complex matters.
How do I know if advice is legitimate?
Legitimate advice uses legal methods and can withstand SARS scrutiny. Be wary of 'guaranteed' schemes or anything that sounds too good. Get opinions in writing.
Next Steps
Ready to find tax expertise?